The Pastor’s Hitman

“All truth is God’s truth.” As a freshman at a Christian college I was being asked to read a book by an atheist, and I was suspicious. The professor refused to apologize that the assigned text was from a nonbeliever, insisting that God’s grace extended even to the New York Times best sellers list.

It’s a simple and fairly obvious idea: not everything is true, but everything that is true is true regardless of who said it. It’s not hard to grasp, but it can be hard to accept.

How Can Christians Know Truth in Today’s World?
Every day, it seems, we read about some campus dust-up over the removal of another book from the curriculum. Works of literature get tossed in the memory hole because the author, it turns out, held beliefs which, however conventional at the time, are now considered politically incorrect. And whether you cheer that as a principled stand or condemn it as another step down the slippery slope to George Orwell’s “1984” depends on where you line up in the culture wars.

But it’s a universal impulse. We all have a tendency to quarantine the things we fear might carry their author’s infection. But should we? If it’s true that all truth is God’s truth do we need to fear that good and true things may carry some hidden contamination?

A former pastor of a midwestern megachurch has been in the news lately because of new, sensational accusations. He had already been fired from the church he started because of financial improprieties and a leadership style that has been described as “bullying.” But add to the long list of accusations about him the new bombshell coming from two different people that he tried finding a hitman to kill someone who he felt posed a threat to his ministry.

Judging by the people I know to still be among the living, this is not a widespread practice among pastors, most of whom remain stubbornly committed to the more biblical if less gratifying approach of “killing them with kindness.”

It’s not surprising at all that this pastor lost his pulpit. It makes complete sense that he has been disinvited from speaking engagements and that his calendar has freed up. But what’s interesting is that bookstores have stopped carrying the books he has written, and publishers have stopped publishing them. And it’s not because there is no longer a market for these books or because anything he wrote is untrue. People are still buying them and reading them and, presumably, benefitting from them.

I have one of those books on my shelf. I read it several years ago and it made a real impact on me at a critical point in my ministry. It breathed fresh air into my preaching and my commitment to the church. It still informs my thinking.

How to Sift for Truth Biblically in a Fallen World
I’m having a tough time reconciling the author of that book with the man who asked his bodyguard to “take care of” a problem for him. And I’m wondering if a book that no longer has a place on the shelves of Christian retailers should have a place on the shelf of my study.

Regarding how to sift through books (as well as movies, music, television, celebrities, memes, etc.) these are some of the conclusions I’ve come to:

1.  Run Everything through a Bible filter. We should be taking a “Berean” approach to all the books we read and authors to whom we give a voice in our lives.  The Bereans were early believers who rigorously ran everything they heard through a Bible filter.  Scripture is, after all, a book where we don’t have to worry about the power of the material or the validity of the Author.
2. Rely on the Holy Spirit for guidance. I can not completely trust any author, any book, or even myself. But I can have complete confidence in the Holy Spirit’s ability to guide me into the truth. “But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth.” (John 16:13)
3. Caution is still warranted. Ideas themselves are not polluted with the other notions held by the mind that conceived and expressed them. But ideas and arguments closely associated with individuals can pull us into the orbit of their authors. John Wesley, for instance, is a thinker whose ideas about sanctification have had a marked effect on my own thinking. I admire him a great deal. And when I read that John Wesley believed that some animals would experience resurrection and a heavenly existence I found myself carefully considering an idea I would probably have dismissed without a thought if it were expressed by anyone else. For better or worse, I’ve been pulled into his intellectual orbit and that would be more dangerous if he were less godly.
4. Look for truth in the fallen world. There is biblical precedent for confidently sifting out the nuggets of gold hidden amidst the world’s gravel.
5. Be Humble. Are there any things you used to be convinced of that you now regard as foolish? Is it possible that there are things you’re convinced of now that you will end up disavowing later? Being humble about our own ability to definitively identify the truth, we should be reluctant to either dismiss or embrace any books, authors, or ideas. Instead, we should keep everything in a sort of quarantine as we work to submit our minds to Jesus.
6. You can and should crowdsource your discernment. If godly people in your life commend a book be more eager to read it If they are throwing up red flags about a book treat it very cautiously. And make sure that those godly people are in your life by participating in a small group or a discipling relationship!
7. Be cautious with creating legitimacy standards. We should be careful about developing standards of legitimacy regarding books and their authors that will, in the end, render all sermons useless for edification, coming as they do from preachers with, invariably, flaws and hypocrisies of their own.
8. When it comes to children a higher degree of scrutiny and caution is justified. The more we grapple with material from unsanctified sources and the more mature we become as thinkers and believers the more immunity we develop (hopefully) to bad and false ideas. But children have not developed those immunities yet. They are more susceptible to virulent thoughts and need more gatekeeping help from the believers in their lives.

Now there have been entire books written on this topic and by better authors than this one. And, as the Teacher says in Ecclesiastes, “of the writing of many books there is no end.” So a blogpost like this one may be of limited value.

But it’s my hope that Christians in an intolerant culture and an incurious age would be set apart by their confident discernment and Holy Spirit led appropriation of all the truth they can get their minds on while carefully spitting out all the nasty stuff before it gets swallowed.

“Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable—if anything is excellent or praiseworthy—think about such things.” Philippians 4:8.

​Written by: Joel Tate 

---